The Count of Monte-Cristo – Spoilers

Don’t say I didn’t warn you.

There are some things I can’t stop thinking about in connection with this book.  It reminds me of how I felt upon finishing Notre-Dame de Paris (no, I didn’t read it in the original French.  I wish I were that fluent….) – horrified and fascinated all at once.

For instance: it’s devastating to think that Mercedes married Fernand while Edmond languished in prison.  But just think – Fernand arranged for Edmond to be imprisoned for the express purpose of marrying Mercedes.  Is it not awful to imagine, for a moment, that Mercedes never married, and was free to wed the newly-escaped Edmond?  For then, Fernand betrayed Edmond Dantes, causing him to be locked away for 14 years… to no purpose.  Sure, it’s upsetting that he was imprisoned to begin with – but to imagine that the very reason for which he was imprisoned came to nothing….  It’s pointless that he was arrested in the first place, but that would be even more pointless, if you understand my meaning.

Another thing – “Andre Cavalcanti” nearly becomes engaged to Eugenie Danglars.  “Andre” is really Benedetto, the long-lost (illegitimate) son of M. Villefort and (his former mistress) Mme Danglars.  Unless I grossly misunderstand something, only Benedetto’s arrest prevents his (unwitting) marriage with his (unknowing) half-sister.  Please correct me if I’m mistaken.

I was genuinely relieved when Albert apologized to the Count and they dispensed with their duel.  I didn’t fancy reading about either dying – and I’d wondered ever since the Count learned of Mercedes’ marriage whether he would spare her – and her son – for his love for her, or punish the entire family (in revenge on Fernand for framing him, Mercedes for deserting him, and Albert for living).

I thought the ending was rather sad.  I know the Count’s affection for Haydee shows that he is capable of moving beyond his past, and I know that he and Mercedes are different from the people they once were, but I feel a little cheated.  It seems as though the Count and Mercedes should have continued their relationship – he’d waited for her for 14 years, and even in ten years beyond that he still felt something of the feeling he’d once had.  I guess that’s just life – people move on, even from true love….

And, to answer the book’s most fundamental question: Can revenge go too far?

Yes.

In the first place, I generally disagree with the Count’s basic position.  Let the law handle things.  In his case, though, the law was against him.  If he told the law of Danglers’s, Coudrousse’s, Villefort’s, and Fernand’s crimes against him, he would again be locked up – if only for escaping prison in the first place.  In the second place, he had no proof.  He couldn’t go to the authorities; he had to take the law into his own hands, so to speak.

However, his forms of revenge affected not only the individuals he wished to injure, but many innocents as well.  Indirectly, he brought about the murder of Valentine Villfort’s maternal grandparents, as well as the deaths of her step-mother and half-brother – and the supposed death of Valentine herself!  Five deaths to avenge himself on one man!  By the time he feels remorse, it’s too late – children have died to satisfy his thirst for vengeance.

 

Perspective

Early last week, one of my plates fell and broke.  It wasn’t a big deal, and I knew it was just a plate, but it still bothered me.  Not that it broke, or that it was my fault – but that I no longer have equal numbers of all my dishes.  I decided to hunt around online, maybe visit a few stores at some point – surely the store from which I bought the set of dishes would also have single plates for sale!

That was the plan, at least.

The next day, I heard that a tornado – two, in fact – had just passed through my Wet State.  My family in the Wet State is safe.  The worst that happened was that some lost power for a few days.

Others weren’t so fortunate.  A few deaths were reported (I’m not sure just how many).  There was a fair amount of building damage.  One high school was separated from its gym.  Trees were uprooted and littered the road.  I’m rather glad that the (rather tall) pine tree next to the Family House in the Wet State was cut down some weeks ago.

And then, of course, life likes to make things interesting all at once.  On Friday, one of the Residents of my Apartment accidentally left the stovetop on after cooking.  Not a big deal, of course – except that we use a gas oven.  No flame was burning to remind us – all I noticed when I came downstairs was a slight smell of gas.  I assumed that it was left over from the cooking, and let it slide at that.  Some time later, one of the other Residents came home from work and remarked on the strong gas smell.  Immediately, she went over the the oven, turned the gas off, and opened the doors and windows.  I’d grown so used to it, I hadn’t noticed how strong it was.

Plates suddenly aren’t such a big deal.

The Count of Monte-Cristo

Note: I tried my best to avoid spoilers.  When I picked this book up, I knew so little about it that the premise was a spoiler.  I tried to be careful.

In case you’ve not picked up on some subtle hints, I love reading.  In fact, to quote a favorite author (I think – I follow so many blogs, I can’t remember precisely who said it), I generally feel like I could do more easily without air than without books.

I decided to challenge myself this last week.  I’ve never read The Count of Monte-Cristo before, but I grew up hearing about how great it is.  I’ve always wanted to read it, but I’ve also always been intimidated by it.  It’s huge. I don’t believe Alexandre Dumas ever heard the words “short story.”  About a week ago, I decided to tackle it.

Wow.

Other words Alexandre Dumas never heard?  Average, simple, predictable, and dull.

All right, I admit it.  I had a hard time in the middle.  But that’s mostly because the beginning fascinated me, and the middle seemed unrelated until I added a few things together.  Even then, I had trouble getting engaged in reading.  Want to know why?

I was too eager for the ending.

The middle’s good, don’t get me wrong.  But it’s the ending I really wanted to read – and it goes against the grain to peek at the back of the book before reading the rest.  I hate  – hate – spoilers.

I think the middle will be easier to read, now that I know how it ends, and how everything fits together.

But this post isn’t meant to discuss how easily I read it.  The point is that it was well worth the patience.

What was so great about it? You have to ask?

It’s a revenge story.  And it’s not just relevant to the characters.  It forces you to think about where you’d draw the line.

If someone ruins your life – not just physically, but he tarnishes your reputation beyond recovery and makes you lose the best years of your life – what would you do about it?  Particularly if the person responsible is your friend – or at least someone you trust.  When you realize what he did – knowingly, deliberately, maliciously – would you strike back?  And if you do, how far do you go?

This question plagued me for the first half of the book.  I’m still trying to wrap my mind about it.  I generally try to be the forgiving type – but this?  I can’t find it in me to blame the Count for wanting vengeance.

The men responsible?  I can understand why they do what they do.  I can sympathize a little, even – not much, mind.  That doesn’t make anything they do right, though.  I can understand why someone would choose a course without condoning that choice.

What really hurts is how close Edmond is at the beginning.  He has everything he wants in life.  He has his happily-ever-after.  Even when things begin to look bad, there still seems to be hope.  He’s so close to getting his happily-ever-after back, to just having a rough experience that he could laugh about a month later, that the reader can feel just how nightmarish it is when simple chance throws everything down the drain.  I can’t speak for all readers, but I really like happy endings.  Even when I knew what was going to happen, I kept hoping Dumas would pull a trick out of his proverbial hat.  I kept hoping – which made it all the worse when hope was completely crushed.

And by then, readers know just how fundamentally good Edmond Dantes is – which makes this change in fortune as bewildering for the reader as for the character, even though we already know all the who‘s and why‘s.

Which brings us to the question:  What would you do if you learned who stole you away from your life thus, if you had the opportunity?

Is revenge worth your humanity?  Can you still be yourself if you retaliate?  Or must you lose the best parts of yourself in gaining revenge?

And – regardless of what the Count of Monte-Cristo feels – is it really worth it?

I know this much.  I’m nowhere near as patient as the Count.  If I made the same resolutions, I wouldn’t be able to wait so long to fulfill them.

Of course, that would probably end up with me being caught and returned to prison.  Which is probably why he waited.  Yet another reason I’m glad I’m not some storybook character….

P.S. If you enjoy the book (and even if you don’t) I highly recommend the songs from the musical.  I haven’t heard them all, but the ones I have heard are exceptional.  They portray exactly how the characters feel during that time in the book.  There were a few songs I wanted desperately to listen to early in the reading process – but I held off just long enough to keep them from spoiling the plot developments.  When I did listen to them, they blew me away – there’s something about music that can just flavor a character, and it’s not something an author can do.  It’s all about the lyrics, the music, and the way they interact.

Pet Peeves

Three days ago, I had intended to walk to a Local Library.  Due to unforeseen weather patterns, I was forced to change my plans, because it was raining.  As you probably know, most people don’t enjoy getting wet, and I hadn’t brought any of my rain gear to work (I was going to walk from my Place of Work to the Library, you see).  Therefore, I was forced to go back to my apartment without new reading material.

The next day, I had planned more carefully.  Rather than just walking outside (as is my want), I looked out the window first.  I saw the rain, grabbed a Rainproof Coat, and went to work.

I had decided on a number of books that I was interested in getting at the Library.  Due to my Foresight, I was able to remember to check out everything that I intended.  Unfortunately, in my own opinion, I suffered great disappointment in one of the books that I had planned to select.  It was available, and I was able to check it out.  The disappointment came later.  When I began reading it, I had a very hard time immersing myself into the plotline of the story.

Any guesses why?

After thinking about it for a while (this happened with the previous book in the series, so I have been thinking about it for a while), I think I’ve come to a conclusion.

The story’s writing is rather passive.  (And, unfortunately, the above use of “want” as seen above is an actual typo I came across.  I’m well aware that it should be “wont.”)  There’s also a lot (read: A LOT) of maid-and-butler going on – at least, that’s how it seems to me.  When the characters talk, there’s little going on between the lines of dialogue – it’s literally little more than “he said, she said.”

And it drives me crazy when characters use a previously-unmentioned-but-highly important element to drive a plot.  That just feels like cheating.  (As I mentioned when talking this over with a family member, if you look at the Harry Potter series, Horcruxes don’t appear out of the blue.  They’re first mentioned by name in book six, but there are references made throughout the entire series.)

If you suffered physical or mental pain reading the first paragraphs, I’m sorry.  I know how much it hurts.

The book I’m reading?  It’s just like that.  All the way through.  I shudder with every page I turn.  And yet…  I’ve stuck with this series for years.  I want to believe that on the next page, things will be better.  I care about the characters – though, I care less the more I read.  It’s hard to care about characters when reading hurts.

Here is another (less passive) way of saying the same thing as in my first paragraphs.  If you disagree, I’m sorry – please leave a comment, and I’ll learn from my mistake(s).

A few days ago, I planned to visit the Local Library.  This was not to be.

Of all days to rain, my Dry State chose that day.  Being my usual scatterbrained self, I forgot to take any precautions as I ran out the door on my way to Work – including a Rainproof coat or an umbrella.  I had a light sweater on, which was good – but not good enough for a Walk To The Library.  At the end of my workday, I looked at the clouds, checked how hard it was raining, and shrugged.  I didn’t have anything due, so there was no rush – though I was rather sad about a Good Book I’d read about online that I’d hoped to check out.  I decided to prepare better the next day.

The next day came.  It was (somehow) still raining.  I grabbed my sweater and a coat to throw on over it as I ran out the door.  It was barely drizzling when I finished Work for the day, so I felt good about visiting the Library.  (By the way, there really should be a verb just for that: going to the Library.)

Some of the books I wanted were there, though not all.  After checking them out, and getting back to my apartment, I sat down and read.

And read.

And read.

The book I’d wanted to read?  Everything I hoped for and more.  The next?  Still amazing.

There was one book I was somewhat hesitant to pick up.  It’s the latest book in a series my family has followed for several years.  I used to love them, but the last one was rather disappointing for us.  I thought I’d give the series another chance.

And now you know… the rest of the story.

 

So Little To Say, Yet So Much Time

Wait!

Strike that.

Reverse it.

Wow, time flies when you’re busy – and things have been insanely busy the last few weeks.  I know I left you hanging with the promise that I’d tell you all about the spies – and I will!  Soon.

First, I need to tell things (somewhat out of order) or I shall surely leave something out!

Over the course of the last several weeks, I have had many adventures.  Hopefully, this explains (or at least provides some context for) the recent lack of Posts regarding the Role of Spies in Three Little Ghosteses:

I’ve packed, moved into a new apartment, and (mostly) unpacked.

In the middle of all this, I spent about a week back in my Wet State.  (Not to be confused with my Dry State – for one thing, it rains more.  Considerably more.  And it’s greener.  I love it!)

While visiting everyone (or as close to everyone as possible) in my Wet State, a close friend made a suggestion regarding short stories and websites.  That was dangerous.  Just look at the results!

As an (only slightly) unforeseen consequence of the aforementioned suggestion, such free time as I have (or, the time when I am not eating, sleeping, or working) has, for the past several days, been largely devoted to preparing stories (and lists of stories, and thinking about stories, and – you get the idea).  I’m afraid I’ve become somewhat obsessed – but that’s a common occurrence when I have a new project to focus my life on.

The plane rides to and from my Wet State were also rather eventful – but that’s a post for another day.

And just to top everything off, I just stumbled upon an excitingly creative website.  Check it out!

Oh, The Games You Will Play

In recent months, I’ve had the privilege (and luxury) of being able to spend time – on a fairly regular basis – with some of my nieces and nephews.  It’s always an adventure.

They don’t play video games.  They don’t use the computer.  They don’t watch many movies.  What do they do with their free time? you ask.

What free time?  They’re too busy playing.

They play board games.  They love card games.  I believe I’ve mentioned my Klein Bottle Bag?  I use it to store my finger puppets – and do I ever have finger puppets!  Those are a hit – several puppet shows have been staged, all with very entertaining results.  If all else fails, they use some Rapunzel Braids (crocheted strands of yarn – thus far unattached to any doll, sadly), tie one end around one of the Rapunzel dolls (or a puppet – they’re not picky) and go “Rapunzel fishing.”

That’s only a small sample of what happens when their imaginations get loose.  Would you like another?  No? Why not?  It’s really interesting, promise.

What?  Oh, all right.  If you insist.

Have you ever heard the nursery rhyme called “Three Little Ghosteses”?

Good.  I’m not the only one.

I’m not entirely sure on the spelling, but it goes something like:

Three Little Ghosteses

Sitting on posteses

Eating buttered toasteses

Greasing their fisteses

Up to their wristeses

Oh, what beasteses

To make such feasteses

One player (determined by the child responsible for choosing the game, generally) goes to a prearranged spot and recites the poem.  Everyone else has to hide (with a beach ball) in the time it takes for the player to recite the rhyme and return.  From here on out, it’s a lot like Hide and Seek, except that the goal isn’t just to hide – you need to hide somewhere so that you can throw the beach ball at the seeker before he finds you.

Not excited yet?  It gets better.  I’ll tell all about the spies in my next post.

A Dark Day for the Fantasy World

I just read Jessica Day George’s blog post.

Then I read the top part again.

I just couldn’t believe it.  Diana Wynne Jones – dead?

I grew up reading Diana Wynne Jones’ books.  I learned about Alternate Universes and Magic from her Chrestomanci books.  I learned to read on those books – I can remember my family reading Witch Week or The Nine Lives of Christopher Chant around the dinner table.  Eventually, I got so impatient with the family drifting into other books that I picked them up and read them through myself.

It was quite some time later that I found other books by Jones that my mom had squirreled away.  Howl’s Moving Castle (which, by the way, I’ve always felt is much better than the movie), its sequel Castle In The Air….  there’s a third one now, which is also good – The House of Many Ways.  The Ogre Downstairs is one I remember reading over and over again;   The Dark Lord of Dirkholm, its sequel The Year of the Griffin….

I remember reading The Dalemark Quartet (The Spellcoats, Drowned Ammet, Cart and Cwidder and The Crown of Dalemark) several times, and never quite understanding everything about the last book.  Or, maybe I did while reading it but became confused while thinking about it later.  Most of her books have been like that for me.

One summer, I decided to go on a Diana Wynne Jones marathon and requested as many of her books from the library as I could find.  Yes, it was somewhat impulsive, but I read several of her books that I’d never heard of – Archer’s Goon (which has since become a favorite), Dogsbody (which is all that Jessica Day George says of it and more), The Eight Days of Luke (a terrific modern-day story enchanted with Norse mythology), The Homeward Bounders (I don’t remember much except that it was good, though the ending was dreadfully sad), Hexwood… the list goes on.

Many of the authors I enjoyed while growing up were from the far past (or so it seemed).  L. Frank Baum’s Oz books, The Secret Garden, Little Lord Fauntleroy, Black Beauty, Jack London’s The Call of the Wild and White Fang….  I was pleasantly surprised when my mom let me in on a secret some years after I started reading – Diana Wynne Jones was still living and writing.  Not only that, but in the last several years, my favorite series of all time – Chrestomanci, of course – gained two more books – two!  After years of believing it was a closed series – all stories told and laid to rest – The Pinhoe Egg and Conrad’s Fate were absolute delights.

I cannot tell everything I feel about her books.  They always catch me by surprise – wonderfully convoluted, yet charmingly simple.  I can never quite remember how a plot twists and turns, which drives me to read it again – but far from boring, it’s an adventure every time.  I’ve always valued her books as the epitome of the fantasy genre.  I’ve loved her character descriptions, which always depict complex and understandable people in a few witty words.

She was an amazing author.  The fantasy world mourns her loss.

In Which The Universe Laughs At My Expense… Again

Be careful what you wish for; you might just get it.

Life decided to take me up on my plea for help a few weeks ago.  I honestly thought I’d be able to sit down sometime that week and churn out the rest of my short story.  I truly believed the words would just keep coming, and I’d have a short story done in record time.  I was wrong.

Well, it’s probably not too late for finishing it in record time – but it’s just a tad overdue for one-week goal.

Of course, it doesn’t help that I’m trying an experiment with all of this.  I’m trying to sharpen my writing skills, and begged invited some of my family to help me.  I’m writing this story in Google Documents.  This is such a clever process (in my humble opinion) that I’m surprised I didn’t think of it before.  I have my master copy, there’s a copy that everyone can access, and everyone also has their own personal copy – all in Google Docs.  I scribble play write in my personal copy.  When a section (they’re not really chapters, as this isn’t supposed to be a novel or anything – it’s supposed to going to be a short story, after all!) is finished to my liking, I copy and paste it into the general copy.  Everyone can see that I’ve made a change, and can copy and paste the new words into their personal copies – which only I have access to, aside from the particular reader.  The reader is then free to comment at will, and I am (relatively) secure in the knowledge that they won’t be influenced by each other’s comments.  (There’s always the possibility that they can look at each other’s documents, but I’m fine with that as long as they only look over the parts they’ve each read and commented on….)

Of course, this has a slight downside.  Google Docs shows when someone last modified the document, regardless of the change.  This means that everyone can see when I add to the story, yes, but it also causes much weeping and distress if they find that I only fixed a typo.

Right, Family?  There is much distress and devastation when you find that I unthinkingly fixed a typo, not adding the rest of the story like you hoped?  (If you disagree, I’m taking you off the Google Docs list.)

(Just kidding.  😛 )

In my defense, I have been rather busy these last few weeks.  I began working at a new job at about the time I started working on this story.  I have Many Important Chores to do, much Exhaustive (if Rarely Performed) Cleaning to accomplish, Libraries to keep in touch with….  It’s a never-ending list.  In fact, if it doesn’t lighten up soon, I may have to take drastic measures.

I may have to declare a book ban.

You’ve never heard of a book ban?  What is it? you ask?  I’ll tell you.  It’s simple, really.  I ban myself from books.  Yes, I know it’s hard to believe – but I’ve survived one so far.  About a year ago, actually.  It was very… enlightening.  In a less-procrastinative sort of way.  Wouldn’t want to do it for very long, of course.  But it is possible.  I promise.

Oh, in recent news – very recent, in fact – I updated my author pages to include Christopher Stasheff.  I can’t believe I forgot about him for so long.  If you like reading about medieval times in alternate universes, this is the author for you!  I hope you find his books as magical as I did – he’s an absolute wizard in writing!

One last thing.  It snowed today, in my Dry State.  It’s just about melted by now, but it was really pretty while it lasted.  I wished I had my camera with me – the trees and bushes were beautiful.  It looked like a Winter Wonderland.

In Urgent Need of Rescue

Please help.  Mind taken over by story.  Is not the story I should be working on.  Must… break… free!

That’s certainly how I’ve felt these last few days.  On Thursday, I thought of a story idea.  I was at work, so I jotted down a few notes during a free moment so I could remember the idea later, and tried to move on.

I failed.

I have so many ideas for stories that I need a binder to hold them all.  I start on one and try to stay focused until it’s done, then I move on to whichever one catches my fancy.

This idea jumped the queue.

My ideas never jump the queue – okay, they do sometimes.  But never this violently!

As I said, I thought of the idea Thursday afternoon.  Throughout Friday, I kept thinking about it, tweaking this idea, writing that idea, thinking of a good line to include.

Disaster struck Saturday.  I should have seen it coming.  I’m always most susceptible to disaster when I’m sleep deprived – and I didn’t get much sleep last week, what with one thing or another.

I started writing.  And kept writing.  And kept writing.  And couldn’t stop writing!

By the time I went to bed, I had 3,000 words.  I don’t know if that sounds like a lot to you, but it’s a record for me!

The next day, I shared it with my family.  Well, parts of it.  Just a little at a time, so I could get feedback along each point.  And I kept writing.  After getting home from church, I spent a solid 10 hours at the computer, glancing at the clock every now and then wondering, where has the time gone?

I ended up with another 3,000 words.  No, strike that.  Nearly 4,000 words.

I was too busy to write yesterday – but it’s close.  It’s really close to being done.  A few things feel rushed, and I might need to add a few more scenes, but (time permitting) I may end the week with a 10,000-word “short” story.

Please help.  Can’t… refuse… the story….

Mission Accomplished

Her pigtails are a little crooked, but that’s only appropriate for a representation of a 3-year-old – right?

Rather than tie each hair stand individually in place (like with 12-year-old Rapunzel), I used a yarn needle to pull several strands through at once, then tied them – very securely – in place with the blue yarn.  I didn’t think ahead very well, so the strands were too short to knot in place….  I might take these pigtails out and put new ones in – I don’t want them to come out – but I don’t think so.  I tied the blue yarn very tightly.  Unless someone tries (very hard) to pull the hair out, it’s not going to happen.  Hopefully….

Yup, just checked.  Those pigtails aren’t going anywhere!

Once again, I’m enjoying the eyebrows.